I researched the cheapest car insurance companies for 2026 so you don't have to. Here is the Top 5 ranking based on price: 5️⃣ Pemco (~$77/mo) 4️⃣ Erie (~$73/mo) 3️⃣ Amica (~$59/mo) 2️⃣ NJM (~$48/mo) 1️⃣ 🤫 [Click to reveal] The #1 winner offers full coverage starting at just $37/mo. It’s not one of the "big names" you see on TV. See who took the top spot in your area here: 👇 | CheapRates Insurance